Claremore Daily Progress


April 18, 2014

Local attorneys fight to eliminate judgment

Petition filed to vacate $27.9M Material Services judgment


Claremore attorneys — Thomas H. Williams and Jack E. Gordon Jr. —   filed a petition Tuesday to vacate the $27.9 million judgment awarded to Material Service Corp. 
 Their strategy is to have the “windfall judgment” voided by the court after the county lost the inverse condemnation case to the mining company in 2012. 
“We have a company that was prohibited from miming for 3 1⁄2 years and essentially they received $10 million a year for not mining and that is outrageous,” Gordon said.
Material Service Corp. filed the action against the county in 2000, claiming the county had improperly annexed 320 acres that prevented the company from mining the land. The lawsuit continued for more than 10 years. 
Now, the attorneys claim the judgment awarded for a 3-1⁄2 year delay of the mining of the Begley Lease near Oologah was won by  “actual fraud of concealment from the court  instead of the actual term” of the lease, according to the documents.
The estimate of the damages awarded to the mining company was based on a 50-year lease, according to the court documents.
Gordon and Williams contend the actual term of the lease was five years with an option to renew.
They assert court records show the term of the lease was omitted when it was filed with the county clerk.
“If the judgment is set aside, then they must pay back the money,” Gordon said. “I hope to recover a nice chunk of change for the county.”
The attorneys also contest the expert testimony of Jim Hinkle and his estimate of damages based on “generally accepted account principles.”
Records show the estimated value of the lease was $7.87 million.
Hinkle’s testimony was based on the claim of a non-existent terminal value of the lease. Gordon and Williams asserts the testimony was confusing, false and fraudulent, according to the documents filed in the case.

Text Only
  • Gas prices continue falling in Oklahoma

    AAA Oklahoma says gas prices continue to drop in the state as demand nationwide drops below 9 million barrels per day.

    July 29, 2014

  • Perry: Texas plans to send 1,000 guardsmen to border

    Texas Gov. Rick Perry plans to deploy as many as 1,000 National Guard troops to South Texas to bolster security along the Mexico border, a local lawmaker confirmed Monday.

    July 21, 2014

  • NASA renames building for Neil Armstrong

    NASA has honored one of its most famous astronauts by renaming a key building at the Kennedy Space Center in Florida.

    July 21, 2014

  • New arrivals worry some in the Oklahoma panhandle

    A family who says they were excommunicated from Warren Jeffs' polygamous sect has moved to a small city located in the Oklahoma Panhandle, raising concerns among some residents.

    July 20, 2014

  • Celebrate 45 years since man's first steps on the moon

    Now's the time to get moonstruck.

    Forty-five years ago Sunday, Apollo 11's Neil Armstrong and Buzz Aldrin became the first humans to set foot on another world. Armstrong's "one small step ... one giant leap" on the dusty lunar surface July 20, 1969, still stirs hearts.

    July 20, 2014

  • US outlines case against Russia on downed plane

    Video of a rocket launcher, one surface-to-air missile missing, leaving the likely launch site. Imagery showing the firing. Calls claiming credit for the strike. Recordings said to reveal a cover-up at the crash site.

    July 20, 2014

  • Oklahoma Capitol renovation project previewed

    State officials have previewed preliminary plans for renovating the century-old Oklahoma State Capitol amid a display of artifacts from groundbreaking ceremonies for the structure.

    July 17, 2014

  • House passes tax breaks to boost charitable giving

    The House passed a package of tax breaks Thursday designed to boost charitable donations by seniors, private foundations and procrastinators.

    One provision provides tax breaks to people over 70 who make donations from their individual retirement accounts. Another reduces excise taxes on private charitable foundations.

    July 17, 2014

  • Should online accounts die when you die?

    Should your emails, web albums and other online accounts die when you do? Or should you be able to pass them down to a family member much as you would a house or a box of letters?

    July 17, 2014

  • Obama, Putin discuss Malaysia Plane incident

    The Kremlin says Russian President Vladimir Putin and President Barack Obama have discussed the Malaysia Airlines plane incident over eastern Ukraine.

    July 17, 2014